Matthew Minchak (G, L, 6’5″, 197, Kingston Frontenacs, 05/23/2007, Colgate) Matthew Minchak is a 6’5′, 197-pound left-catching goaltender who possesses prototypical NHL size and a solid statistical foundation, making him a credible draft candidate with projection tied to consistency. In 30 OHL games (2.91 GAA, .910 SV%, 1 shutout), he has shown the ability to handle a moderate workload (28 shots against per game) while maintaining a stable save percentage, and his performance aligns with prior Neutral Zone evaluations that highlight strong puck tracking, composure, and the ability to get set quickly on lateral plays, particularly on passes from below the goal line. His size is a clear asset. He fills the net naturally and does not need to overextend to make saves, and when he is square and set, he is difficult to beat cleanly. His positional play and tracking allow him to control first touches effectively, and his goals against are in line with expected metrics, meaning he is not giving up soft goals. However, there are still notable areas of concern that limit his projection: despite his size, he can play too deep in his crease, relying on his frame rather than challenging shooters, which can expose the net, and his puck play is a weakness, limiting his ability to create transition or aid breakouts. Additionally, while he tracks well, his rebound control can be inconsistent, particularly on shots from distance, leading to second-chance opportunities from the low slot, and his overall athleticism and explosiveness are average rather than dynamic, which may limit his ability to recover on NHL caliber shooters. While his .910 save percentage is respectable, it does not separate him from peers, and he has yet to demonstrate elite performance in high-danger situations. Overall, Minchak has the size, tracking ability, and baseline consistency to warrant NHL draft consideration, and I do believe he has a pathway to becoming an NHL goaltender, but I believe it will take time. For me he projects as a longer-term development goalie whose ceiling will depend on improving crease depth management, puck handling, and rebound control to complement his natural size advantage.
Photo credit: Dan Hickling/Hickling Images